Logo
Insights Logo
Working Papers
Complimentary CONTENT

Replacing Cross-Validation with Interrogation

May 7, 2025
By: Megan Czasonis, Yin Li, Huili Song, David Turkington

By Megan Czasonis, Yin Li, Huili Song, and David Turkington

 

Our innovative "interrogation" method detects unreliable machine learning predictions in advance, overcoming limitations of the traditional cross-validation method.

 

We introduce a new method called "interrogation" to warn when a machine learning model has underfit or overfit a data sample, offering a more efficient alternative to traditional cross-validation. Unlike cross-validation, which can be cumbersome and computationally expensive, interrogation evaluates models trained on all available data by breaking down their prediction logic into linear, nonlinear, pairwise, and high-order interaction components. This method successfully identified near-optimal stopping times for training neural networks without using validation samples, boosting confidence that models are well-calibrated and can perform reliably on new data. Interrogation is model-agnostic, providing transparency and reliability even for black-box models.

 

READ THE 1-PAGE SUMMARY

Author Bios
Megan Czasonis
Megan Czasonis is a Managing Director and Head of Portfolio Management Research at State Street Associates. The Portfolio Management Research team collaborates with academic partners to develop new research on asset allocation, risk management, and investment strategy. The team delivers this research to institutional investors through indicators, advisory projects, and thought leadership pieces. Megan has co-authored various journal articles and works closely with institutional investors to develop customized solutions based on this research. Megan graduated Summa Cum Laude from Bentley University with a B.S. in Economics / Finance.
Yin Li
Yin Li is a Quantitative Researcher on the Portfolio Management Research team at State Street Associates. He is responsible for developing and implementing quantitative tools that support SSA’s initiatives in currency hedging, asset allocation, and investment strategy.
Huili Song
Huili Song is a Vice President and Quantitative Researcher at State Street Associates (SSA). Since joining SSA in 2020, Huili has worked on quantitative applications of SSA's research and led product development initiatives for State Street Markets' research platform - Insights, offering intuitive and interactive way to engage with indicator products and research. Her research focuses on data-driven analysis and statistical learning in the realm of asset predictions, portfolio construction and risk management. Huili holds a Bachelor of Science Degree in Applied Mathematics from Shanghai Jiao Tong University and a Master of Finance Degree from Massachusetts Institute of Technology, with a concentration in financial engineering.
David Turkington
David Turkington is Senior Managing Director and Head of State Street Associates, State Street Markets’ decades-long partnership with renowned academics that produces innovative research on markets and investment strategy. David is a frequent presenter at industry conferences, has published more than 40 research articles in a range of journals, and serves on the editorial board of the Journal of Alternative Investments. He is the co-author of three books including “Asset Allocation: From Theory to Practice and Beyond” and “Prediction Revisited: The Importance of Observation.” His published research has received the 2010 Graham and Dodd Scroll Award, five Bernstein-Fabozzi/Jacobs-Levy Outstanding Article Awards, the 2013 Peter L. Bernstein Award for best paper in an Institutional Investor journal, the 2021 and 2023 Roger F. Murray First Prize for outstanding research presented at the Q Group seminars, and the 2022 and 2023 Harry Markowitz awards for best paper in the Journal of Investment Management.
State Street Logo
1. Peter L. Bernstein Award for Best Article in an Institutional Investor Journal in 2013; Bernstein-Fabozzi/Jacobs-Levy Award for Outstanding Article in the Journal of Portfolio Management in 2006, 2009, 2011, 2013 (2), 2014, 2015, 2016, 2021; Graham & Dodd Scroll Award for article in the Financial Analysts Journal in 2002 and 2010. Roger F. Murray First Prize for Research Presented at the Q Group Conference in 2012, 2021, 2023. Harry M. Markowitz Award for Best Paper in the Journal of Investment Management in 2022, 2023. Doriot Award for Best Private Equity Research Paper in 2022.